Evil Eye vs Rainbow Butterfly Enamel Keychain: Which to Pick?
By THESE ARE THINGS® – Enamel Pins • Iron On Patches | Published: 2026-11-02
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Evil Eye and Rainbow Butterfly enamel keychains on size, shape, and meaning to choose the right charm for your keys, bag, or gift.
Quick answer
Choose the Evil Eye Enamel Keychain if you want a compact, protective symbol with a classic look; choose the Rainbow Butterfly Enamel Keychain if you prefer a wider, colorful charm that adds a playful pop to bags or keys.
Size and shape: how they sit on your gear
The Evil Eye keychain is 2.25 inches tall by 1.25 inches wide, so it stays narrow and vertical—less likely to snag or crowd a key ring. The Rainbow Butterfly is 2.25 inches wide, giving it a broader, horizontal spread that reads clearly from a distance but may feel bulkier on a tight keychain.
Both attach with a split key ring, so switching between keys, bags, or backpacks is equally easy. The difference is purely how much visual space the charm takes up.
Meaning and style: protection vs playfulness
The Evil Eye is traditionally associated with protection and warding off negative energy, which makes it a meaningful, understated choice for everyday carry. The Rainbow Butterfly leans into whimsy and color, with a vibrant rainbow design that resists fading thanks to its enamel construction.
Neither is inherently better—your pick depends on whether you want a subtle symbol with a story or a bright accessory that lifts your mood.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Space on your key ring: If you carry many keys or fobs, the Evil Eye’s 1.25-inch width leaves more room; the Rainbow Butterfly’s 2.25-inch width takes up more space but is easier to spot. Test your key ring with a similarly sized object before committing.
- Symbolism vs color: The Evil Eye offers a classic protective meaning; the Rainbow Butterfly offers a playful, colorful look. Pick the one that matches the message you want your accessory to send.
- Gift appeal: For a small, meaningful gift, the Evil Eye suits someone who appreciates tradition; the Rainbow Butterfly suits someone who loves bright, whimsical accessories. Both come from These Are Things and use durable enamel. Consider the recipient’s usual style before choosing.
Product facts
- Rainbow Butterfly Enamel Keychain: Measures 2.25 inches wide (excluding the key ring) with a vibrant rainbow butterfly design. The wider profile makes it a visible, cheerful statement on a backpack or tote.
Rainbow Butterfly Enamel Keychain - Evil Eye Enamel Keychain: Measures 2.25 inches tall by 1.25 inches wide (excluding the key ring) and features an evil eye design. The narrow shape keeps it compact on a crowded key ring while still showing its protective symbol.
Evil Eye Enamel Keychain
Which one is right for you?
Best for
- Shoppers who want a compact, protective charm for everyday keys
- Gifts for someone who appreciates subtle symbolism and classic design
Not for
- People who prefer a bold, colorful accessory that stands out
- Anyone who needs a wider charm to easily spot in a bag
